top of page
Search
Handstone Evora Collection mid-century solid wood dining room, Canadian-made and available through Oak Unlimited in Bowmanville

Handstone vs Cardinal Woodcraft Dining: A Dealer's Guide to Choosing

Sep 30
4 min read

Handstone and Cardinal Woodcraft both build solid wood dining furniture to order in Ontario, so you cannot go wrong on quality with either one. The choice usually comes down to style, wood options and how the chairs feel, and you can compare both makers side by side at Oak Unlimited in Bowmanville.



Key takeaways


  • Both are Ontario makers that build Canadian-made solid wood furniture to order.

  • Handstone, from Wallenstein, builds whole-home collections in cherry, maple and red oak.

  • Cardinal Woodcraft, from the Elmira area, specializes in custom dining tables, chairs and sideboards.

  • Choose Handstone to match other rooms in your home, or Cardinal for maximum flexibility in the dining room.

  • Oak Unlimited carries both, so you can compare them in one visit.



Handstone vs Cardinal Woodcraft: the short answer


The biggest difference is focus. Handstone builds complete collections such as Tribeca, Pemberton and Evora that span the dining room, bedroom and living room, all in cherry, maple and red oak. Cardinal Woodcraft concentrates on the dining room, with custom tables, chairs and sideboards handcrafted by local Mennonite craftspeople. Both build to order, so either one can be made to suit your space.



About each maker


Handstone of Wallenstein


Handstone is a family-owned Ontario maker founded in 1999. Its craftspeople hand-select cherry, maple and red oak, hand-sand every piece and finish it with a durable post-catalyzed coating. Designs are drawn with CAD precision, and most pieces can be built to custom dimensions. You can learn more on our Handstone partner page or in our Handstone buyer's guide.


Cardinal Woodcraft of the Elmira area


Cardinal Woodcraft began as a small furniture maker in Elmira, Ontario, and it still works from the same area while supplying dealers across Canada. It specializes in custom solid wood tables, chairs and sideboards made from locally sourced wood, with each piece custom-designed and handcrafted by local Mennonite craftspeople. Read more on our Cardinal Woodcraft partner page.



Style and design


Because Handstone's dining pieces belong to whole-home collections, your dining set can match a bedroom or living room down the hall. Tribeca is modern and geometric, Pemberton is sculpted and nature-inspired, and Evora is warm and mid-century. Our comparison of Tribeca, Pemberton and Evora looks at each one in detail.


Cardinal keeps its attention on the dining room, with a range that runs from relaxed kitchen tables to large formal tables. Styles such as Madrid, Tuscany and Black Sea are featured on our Cardinal Woodcraft dining collection page, and because every table is custom made, shape and size are remarkably flexible.


Cardinal Woodcraft Tuscany round solid wood dining table, chairs and sideboard, handcrafted by Mennonite craftspeople in Ontario


Wood, stain and finish


Handstone builds in cherry, maple and red oak, with a range of stains and a post-catalyzed finish made for everyday use. Cardinal builds in locally sourced solid wood with its own choice of stains, and options vary by style. The best way to compare them is to look at both makers' samples together, under the same light, next to a sample of your own flooring or cabinets. Our guide to the best wood for your dining table can help you narrow it down.



Comfort and chairs


For most people, the chairs are what make the decision. Seat height, depth, back angle and whether you want upholstery all change how a table feels through a long meal. Cardinal offers a wide range of dining chairs, including upholstered options, and Handstone offers chairs designed to pair with its tables. Sit in both before you choose.


Handstone Pemberton Collection solid wood dining room with sculpted curves, handcrafted in Ontario and available at Oak Unlimited


Comparison at a glance



Handstone

Cardinal Woodcraft

Location

Wallenstein, Ontario

Elmira area, Ontario

Focus

Whole-home collections

Dining tables, chairs and sideboards

Styles at Oak Unlimited

Tribeca, Pemberton and Evora

Madrid, Tuscany, Black Sea and more

Wood

Hand-selected cherry, maple and red oak

Locally sourced solid wood

Customization

Wood, stain and size

Wood, stain, size and shape



Questions to bring to the showroom


Thinking through a few questions before your visit will point you toward one maker or the other:


  • How many people do you seat most nights, and how many during the holidays?

  • Would you like your dining set to match other rooms in the house?

  • Which wood and stain suit your floors and cabinets?

  • Do you prefer upholstered chairs or solid wood seats?

  • Would a sideboard or buffet help with storage?


Bring your answers with you and Mark and Denise can work through them with both catalogues in hand.



Which one should you choose?


Neither maker is better across the board, since both build quality solid wood to order in Ontario. Choose Handstone if you want your dining set to match a Tribeca, Pemberton or Evora bedroom or living room. Choose Cardinal if you want a dining specialist with wide flexibility in table shape, size and chair style.


The easiest way to decide is to see them together. Oak Unlimited at 95 King St W in historic downtown Bowmanville is a family-run dealer for both makers, so you can sit at their tables, try the chairs and compare stain samples in a single visit. Floor models change, so call ahead if there is a specific piece you want to see.




Frequently asked questions


Is Handstone or Cardinal Woodcraft better for a dining room?


Both build high-quality solid wood dining furniture to order in Ontario. Handstone suits you if you want your dining set to match other rooms, while Cardinal Woodcraft suits you if you want a dining specialist with more flexibility in shape and size.


Can I mix Handstone and Cardinal Woodcraft pieces?


Often, yes. Pairing a table from one maker with a sideboard or chairs from another can work well when the wood and stain are coordinated. Bring your ideas to the showroom and we will show you which combinations look right together.


Where can I see Handstone and Cardinal Woodcraft side by side?


At Oak Unlimited in historic downtown Bowmanville, where we carry both makers on one showroom floor.


See Handstone and Cardinal Woodcraft side by side at 95 King St W in downtown Bowmanville.


 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page